Yeah, sure, but why don’t we try to test it out? The thing is: why shouldn’t you post some voice stuff? We could just put a limit on the duration to prohibit posts longer than about three minutes or so. But okay, there’s surely a reason why the admin didn’t just do it that way right away.

Why should this one be mixed. This is only for admin contact and some feedback, nothing more. Again though, on the rest, all the points you brought up I already mentioned.

This one not, I also don't think that this may be a good idea. But maybe every one aside this.

What about an audio forum like before? or a mixed one?

I think that's what the show and tell forum is for, I could be wrong.

there is already one

The show and tell forum is a mixed forum@25

The Community Extras forum is also mixed

Maybe, rename trash into archive, sounds more friendly. Also because of the fact that we have so many music producing/posting your favorite song threads now that it's all the same by now. So might have to archive some other ones. Or, put them together. Idk.

Maybe putting them together will be fine.

OK, what I'll do for now is keeping the thread that Rudolf made and the play on your instruments thread distinct. Rudolf's thread will be for general tips, tricks and asking for help, while the other thread will be for actually showing off your work and getting feedback on it. Thoughts?

yeah, maybe rename the trash topic to archive.

To be fair the instrument sing etc thread has a huuuuge number of posts. It takes ages to load. So not really up for it. If elten wouldn't lag it out like crazy, then yes.
Don't think this thread should've been brought over tbh, it served well in the archive to view.

I think we should keep the instrument thing as it is, and if it's goes to 1500 posts maybe open a new one to reduce loading times.
I think we either could merge my thread and music producers unite, or move all audio posts from my topic to that one and keeping my one for advices - as you suggested it - about DJing. That way people can showcase their own creations well enough in the unite thread, but for in dept discussion or more generalized tips they can refer to my thread.
This way we would have an analog showcase thread, a digital showcase thread and a digital discussion thread.

Thoughts on making an archive forum of the historical or significant threads that got too huge and we can recreate new continuations? I did say that a lot of the threads we brought over would end up being archived remember?

I think we could set some caps for the threads, like, idk. The Suno topic reaching 1k posts, the music topic 1.5k etc. For me it just looks better haha.

Yeah. For voice posts I wouldn't do a limit based on if it's suno or not, that's dumm. But more like, 1500, 2k, something like that. Call it that name with an Old before or behind it, and then there can be a new one with the same name. In the german one, we had part 1 2 3 4 5 on a bunch of threads, that looked a bit stupid name wise.

OK no.
I just realised that Starchild made a thread with the intention of showing off music productions, but I also tried opening the sing on your musical instruments thread and it took about 35 seconds to load. That's unacceptable to me so this is what I'm going to do. I'm closing that one, and we will use Starchild's thread as a replacement, and we'll keep Rudolf's thread open to share tips and tricks.

Thats a very great idea.

This is a suggestion for the admins. What about removing blank audio posts and empty text posts if you encounter one please? The previous admins has done it before and I don't see there's a problem doing so.
thanks.