@178, wait are you commenting on the post? If yes, and you're saying it sounds like AI, then I have to say. It seems like you're saying things just for saying things sake.

I was actually responding to what Rudolf said, as it can be well seen and checked in my answer post. For me it really sounded like a post which was half-checked and corrected by AI, and at some time the poster got bored and dropped it as it is.

I don't see it at all. The grammar errors, the spelling errors, the word choice, sentence structure, nothing about it looks AI.

Some unfinshed house-ish song.

I have a feeling we have already heard this loop from you but in a different key and faster. But I could be wrong.
Could you at least create these melodies yourself? I can also stick loops together in ableton and call it a day.

I wonder what leads you both (I see who likes the same posts) to such an interesting assumtion, especially assuming that it is me who over all doesn't create the best mixes anyway? I could say the same about Roma as well, accusing him of stealing entire songs since they sound to professional or whatever I would be mooded like to come up with. I don't think I ever have used this melody, but even if this was the case, would there be an issue for you in using the same melody multiple times as long as it isn't being done excessively? Before talking, I'd love to see a track from you that is better than mine, but I'm glad to open up the discussion again. And as a last heads up, this song is entirely selfmade, using no more than a few stock plugins, some Ableton built-in devices, and a few Cymatics samples. I'd appreciate it if you'd put your toxicity somewhere else. What comes next, accusing me that these songs perhaps are done using AI?

One moment, did you possibly use a DAW for this? How do you dare. You must craft music with your own instruments and nothing more than a physical metronome and loop machine. Seriously though it's really not that deep, I mean music is music, like rather be happy he's not one of these AI music idiots which post every of their suno creations everywhere and think they did something awesome.
And if it bothers you so much you have to work on your ignorance skills.

A metronome? This looks like a cheat was being detected here. You only can craft music by ear, and entirely physical.

Uh, I didn't know creating your own melodies and using a DAW is the same. Everyone learns something new every day it seems.

-- (Jonathan):
One moment, did you possibly use a DAW for this? How do you dare. You must craft music with your own instruments and nothing more than a physical metronome and loop machine. Seriously though it's really not that deep, I mean music is music, like rather be happy he's not one of these AI music idiots which post every of their suno creations everywhere and think they did something awesome.
And if it bothers you so much you have to work on your ignorance skills.

--

Lol how the fuck is using loops a problem, I know people making music for like 15 years or something and they slap splice loops on their tracks cuz why the shit not, sounds good, just for fun. Stop crying.
-- (ArcticMoon):
Uh, I didn't know creating your own melodies and using a DAW is the same. Everyone learns something new every day it seems.

-- (Jonathan):
One moment, did you possibly use a DAW for this? How do you dare. You must craft music with your own instruments and nothing more than a physical metronome and loop machine. Seriously though it's really not that deep, I mean music is music, like rather be happy he's not one of these AI music idiots which post every of their suno creations everywhere and think they did something awesome.
And if it bothers you so much you have to work on your ignorance skills.

--

--

then again there was that one time where Kendric Lamar sampled some US anthom thing in one of his songs... But oh well

Yeah I don't see the problem here. Using loops and samples is so common in modern music.

Sampling is a creative process though, while a loop is basically a few samples put together, which has been likely used by thousands of other producers, or at least that's how I understand it.

And the problem with that is? Lol I don't understand why yall care so much about that little thing but people dumping the internet with AI music and other crap is fun or something. Like go care about some seriouss problems.

Lol one doesn't exclude the other, a crappy song will be crappy regardless of whether AI made it or not.
And have you ever listened to the radio or popular Spotify playlists? Same drums, same melodies, same vocal styles. This should hopefully answer your question.
It's boring.

It doesn't. Meh this argument is childish just gonna drop it. @Garo don't feel discurraged I guess. It's an acceptable start and will improve for sure.
-- (djsenter):
Lol one doesn't exclude the other, a crappy song will be crappy regardless of whether AI made it or not.
And have you ever listened to the radio or popular Spotify playlists? Same drums, same melodies, same vocal styles. This should hopefully answer your question.
It's boring.

--

It's based on facts, and because you don't like it, it's childish.
Anyway pointing something out isn't in no shape or form meant to be discouraging.
@Roma love that beat, gonna freestyle on it rofl.

Worked more on the piece from post 184.

Quite pleasant, it lacks some synth lead that would tie it all together.

-- (rudolf):
Worked more on the piece from post 184.

--